I commit to “listening” to all differing opinions on every issue while being prepared to make the tough decisions I believe are best for Dunnville and Haldimand County.

The MZO is a perfect example. I have reviewed information both for and against the proposal and have serious concerns that need to be addressed.

I will continue listening to Ward 5 residents before formalizing my final position.

An Issue That Has Dominated the Conversation

Over the last 4 years this one issue has dominated much of our conversation. So much so, that many other issues facing the County have not received much needed attention.

Housing availability and affordability, our infrastructure, support for business, agriculture, industrial growth, healthcare, public safety, accessibility to name a few.

Because of the divisiveness which has hurt us significantly. A priority for us should be restoring professionalism and with it the public’s trust.

Traffic, Road Safety and Infrastructure

Many residents have shared concerns about the potential traffic congestion, road safety, and the difficulty that might be experienced getting to, entering, and exiting the busy area, given existing road infrastructure is already strained.

Our decision must not only be based on the concerns voiced about the number of homes proposed but also on whether our existing local and leading thereto, roads and infrastructure can safely and economically support the additional growth.

Some will argue it’s a given that infrastructure will follow, be it by the developer or those responsible in the normal course to provide it — i.e. the County, or senior levels of government — but in my view the gamble is significant.

The delays in securing the infrastructure improvements to support the pace of housing could have a negative impact on quality of life and cost us heavily in the long run.

Based on my review, I do not believe we fully account for the cumulative impact of increasing density on our transportation network or the impacts that additional traffic has on existing residents without corresponding infrastructure improvements.

Stelco and the Local Economy

There are as many pros as there are cons which includes Stelco’s opposition, and I am eager to hear from Ward 5 residents when going door to door.

Having said this, the major concern to me remains Stelco’s opposition to the proposed development, which is on record.

The main reason being, and this is not being talked about by either side, is the unpredictability of the current U.S. administration as it relates to tariffs and protectionism (made in the U.S.A). The most recent trade talks breakdown is just another example of the uncertainty we face.

There should be a heightened concern that we could potentially be providing Cleveland-Cliffs Inc., the U.S.-based owners who purchased Stelco for U.S. $2.5 billion in 2024, a reason, because of their government’s pressure, to take some or all of the Lake Erie Works part of their business south.

While a commitment was made to the Canadian government that even with the 100% U.S. ownership, Stelco’s head office (finishing and coating) would remain in Hamilton, from what I know, nothing was said that as an additional condition of the approval, the Lake Erie operations (fully integrated steel making) would be kept operating.

Although unlikely to happen in any event, do we roll the dice giving them an excuse to shut it down despite the multi-billion-dollar investment in the purchase and operation?

Power Generation and the Development Footprint

Also, how would proceeding with a housing development impact power generation initiatives given the Province’s recent $500,000 funding announcement?

In the final analysis, a better approach might be to negotiate with the developer for an even smaller footprint there and/or enter discussions about different lands more suitable for residential development.

Council Must Make Its Own Decision

While developers have the right to appeal decisions at the OLT, or as in this case, a decision pending from the Ontario government after their recent public consultation, that should not dictate how councillors vote!

Our responsibility is to make decisions based on sound planning, public safety, and the long-term interests of our communities.

My vote will be based on the capacity of our road networks and infrastructure, the cumulative impact on existing residents and business/industry, and the safety of both current and future residents.

To simply say no could expose us to a “be careful what you ask for” scenario. That is, the potential for a data centre(s) and resulting significant draw on water and hydro, with very little to show for it in terms of investment in the community and few jobs created.

✓ KEY POINTS
  • I have serious concerns with the proposal that need to be addressed.
  • Existing roads and infrastructure must be able to safely and economically support additional growth.
  • The cumulative impact of increasing density on our transportation network must be considered.
  • Stelco’s opposition and the potential impact on the Lake Erie Works are major concerns.
  • A smaller footprint or different lands more suitable for residential development should be considered.
  • Council’s vote should be based on sound planning, public safety, infrastructure capacity and the long-term interests of our communities.
♡ WHY THIS MATTERS

Over the last four years this one issue has dominated much of our conversation, while many other issues facing the County have not received much needed attention.

While I support responsible and smart growth and recognize the need for more housing, growth must be matched with infrastructure that can safely accommodate it.

Our responsibility is to make decisions based on sound planning, public safety, and the long-term interests of our communities.